Why the bristle design falls short for toe cleaning
The silicone bristles on the MudBuster are intentionally soft and flexible to be gentle on your dog's paws - which is great if your dog hates having their feet touched. But that same softness means they lack the stiffness needed to penetrate deep between toes and scrub out compacted mud. Think of it like using a soft toothbrush on plaque buildup; it's gentle but not aggressive enough for the job.
The bristle spacing also matters. Dogs with wide, spread feet might have better luck since the bristles can reach more surface area. But narrow paws - common in breeds like whippets, greyhounds, and similar sighthounds - just don't get adequate coverage. The bristles end up poking rather than scrubbing, leaving dirt trapped in the crevices where it matters most.
Related: -Dexas MudBuster Portable Dog Paw Cleaner xsmall good for ...
What actually works in real-world use
Owners report mixed results depending on their situation. If your dog gets wet, muddy paws that need a quick rinse, the MudBuster does the job fine. One reviewer with a boxer puppy found it was a lifesaver for sandy paws - she could get them completely clean, and her dog even started volunteering her paws when she saw it coming out. Another owner with large German Shepherds said it significantly reduced the mud tracked into the house.
Related: -Dexas MudBuster Portable Dog Paw Cleaner large for 60 lb ...
But if your dog comes in with thick, clay-like mud caked around the pads and between the toes - which is exactly when you need help most - you'll likely need to follow up with a towel or rag to finish the job. The product works best as a first-pass cleaning tool rather than a complete solution. Some owners change the water after every paw or two to avoid using dirty water, which helps, but doesn't solve the bristle-depth problem.
Size matters too. The three available sizes (Small, Medium, and Large) help with fit, but fit alone doesn't guarantee thorough cleaning. A dog whose paw is too small for the cup means half their leg goes inside, making it awkward to use properly. Conversely, paws that are too large for the bristles to grip effectively won't get cleaned between the toes no matter the size you choose.
Getting better results if you already own one
If you have the MudBuster, use it strategically. Fill it with warm water - reviewers note this helps - and focus on the initial rinse to remove loose mud and water. Then follow up with a soft cloth or towel to manually clean between the toes. Keep it by the door for quick post-walk cleanups rather than expecting it to handle heavy mud situations alone. For dogs that hate having their paws handled, it's genuinely useful because they tolerate the bristles better than aggressive towel scrubbing or hose spray.
The MudBuster is practical for everyday maintenance and keeps your floors cleaner, but it's not a complete replacement for manual paw cleaning when mud gets between the toes.
